Most high level players tell you that the only way to know if an item is an upgrade is to run it through a complex computer simulation. While those tools are very accurate, not everyone wants to use them or has the time to do it every time a new item drops. “How to Evaluate an Upgrade With Zero Sim Tools” is a guide for the rest of us. It will teach you how to use basic logic and a few simple rules to decide if that new piece of loot is actually worth wearing.

Evaluating gear yourself helps you understand your character better. Instead of just doing what a website tells you, you will learn why certain stats are good and how they interact with your spells. this knowledge makes you a better player because you will understand the strengths and weaknesses of your character. you can make quick decisions in the middle of a raid and feel confident that you are making the right choice for your performance.

the golden rule of item level

The easiest way to check for an upgrade is to look at the item level. In most cases, if an item is ten levels higher than what you are wearing, it is probably an upgrade. This is because higher level items have more primary stats like strength, agility, or intellect. these stats are the foundation of your power and almost always beat out the smaller secondary stats like haste or crit. if the item level jump is large, you do not need a computer to tell you to put it on.

However, if the item level is the same or only a tiny bit higher, the decision becomes more difficult. This is where you have to look at the secondary stats. if an item has five more item levels but has your two worst stats, it might actually be a sidegrade or even a small loss. but for most players, especially while leveling or starting out, following the item level is a safe and effective strategy that works most of the time.

how to rank your secondary stats

• identify your best stat: most classes have one stat they want as much as possible. find out what yours is and look for it on every piece of gear.
• look for the pair: gear usually comes with two secondary stats. an upgrade often has your top two stats, while a bad item has your bottom two.
• check for sockets: a socket for a gem is worth a lot of secondary stats. a lower level item with a socket is often better than a higher level item without one.
• consider the slot: for some items like rings and necks, there is no primary stat. in these cases, the secondary stats are the only thing that matters, so item level is less important.
• don’t forget the tier set: if you have a set bonus from a raid, do not replace those items even for much higher level gear until you can get the bonus back on the new pieces.

the feel test in combat

If you are not sure about an item, put it on and go fight something. Pay attention to how your character feels. If you swap a lot of mastery for haste, does your rotation feel faster and smoother? do you have fewer moments where you are waiting for resources? sometimes the numbers on a screen do not tell the whole story about how an item affects your actual gameplay experience.

If the game feels clunky or you are running out of energy too fast with the new item, it might not be the right choice for you right now. A character that feels good to play is often a character that is being played more effectively. trust your instincts and your experience as much as the numbers. if you are having more fun and things are dying at a good pace, you made a good choice.

using common sense for trinkets and weapons

Weapons and trinkets are special cases where you should be more careful. For weapons, the damage range and the primary stat are so important that you should almost always take the higher item level. for trinkets, the unique effect is king. read the text on the trinket and ask yourself if it actually helps you in the things you are doing. a trinket that gives you a bonus only when you stand still is not very good if you are doing a dungeon that requires a lot of movement.

Think about the situations you face most often. If a trinket procs once every three minutes but your average fight only lasts two minutes, you are not getting the full value out of it. evaluate these special items based on your actual playtime, not just their theoretical power. using common sense and looking at how you actually spend your time in game will lead you to the right gear choices every time.

conclusion: trust your own judgment

Evaluating upgrades with zero sim tools is a valuable skill that every player should learn. By following the item level rule, ranking your stats, and using the feel test, you can make smart decisions about your gear. you do not need to be a slave to a website to have a powerful character. trust your own judgment, learn how your stats work, and enjoy the feeling of building a character that you truly understand. the best gear is the gear that helps you win your next battle.

Home